|
“I'll be a virgin for you and lay my body down
cause I know more tricks than a rodeo clown"
-Julie Brown (from
the movie Medusa: Dare to Be Truthful)
 Howard Kurtz Last Sunday was my first exposure to an obnoxious jerk named
Glenn Beck. I’ve managed to live 48 years without ever hearing, reading or
seeing any of Mr. Beck’s work as a
“commentator,” but he recently showed up
on one of my favorite television programs, CNN’s Reliable Sources, hosted by
Howard Kurtz.
During the interview,
Beck said he was not a journalist but more like a “rodeo clown.”
Reliable Sources examines the media and does it well. Beck was
questioned about some of his outlandish statements. It was also a chance for
the network to showcase Beck, who appears
on CNN Headline News, an affiliate of CNN.  Danielle Morgan
Kurtz did a decent job questioning Beck, but the segment was
a waste of time. Beck was treated too much like a serious journalist and not
enough like a self-described “rodeo clown”.
I watch Reliable Sources to learn about journalism. If I want
to watch rodeo clowns, I’ll watch the rodeo.
It made me wonder if another Kurtz, Ken Kurtz, would have
booked a guest like Beck.
The Kentucky Journalism Hall of Fame is naming Ken Kurtz as
a member next month. It is an overdue honor for one of Kentucky’s best newsmen.
Ken was the long-time news director at WKYT television in Lexington. Although he has “retired” from journalism for
several years, someone forgot to tell Ken. He is still one of the best
newshounds in Kentucky.
A man who has the inside scoop. His
enthusiasm for news-gathering and for life is contagious.
He is a nice guy, but I suspect he was a demanding boss. He
frequently sends me criticisms of my column as well as ideas for
improvement.
Yet even when expressing disagreement, he is still tolerant of others’ viewpoints and is never personal
or mean.
That is what separates him from the Glenn Beck’s of the
world. To grab attention, Beck pushes the envelope on how obnoxious he can be.
Being outrageous is a
quicker path to fame and glory than serious journalism. Ann Coulter is making
more money than the people who win Pulitzer prizes. Beck probably is too.
I wonder if the Ken Kurtz news model can survive.
Ken’s broadcasts were first in the ratings and usually by a
wide margin. He built his broadcasts on local talent, hard news and pleasant on-camera
personalities. If you meet the reporters that Ken hired, like Barbara Bailey or
Bill Bryant, they are just as nice off
air as they appear on air. They are also serious journalists.
I’ve never heard Barb and Bill refer to themselves as rodeo
clowns.
A Ken Kurtz news broadcast was a newscast, not an opinion show.
A true television newscast is getting hard to find. CNN Headline News used to be my first choice, but I quit watching it when they
started featuring “commentators” like
Beck and Nancy Grace.
For the sake of ratings, many stations forgo political
coverage and focus on sex, blood and drugs. Because it works, that
trend will increase in the future.
I frequently watch WYMT’s newscasts from Hazard on my
computer. You can tell that Neil Middleton, the news director, was trained by
Ken Kurtz. Neil’s broadcasts have friendly,
home-grown reporters who do serious news.
There may be a day when Middleton sends his angelic news anchor Danielle
Morgan (daughter of a Leslie
County preacher) to pose as
an undercover street hooker, but it hasn’t happened yet.
I hope it never does.
I know that being edgy sells. My most outrageous columns are
the ones people remember, and they are also the ones that get tons of hate
mail.
I don’t write to get ratings; I write because I am mad and want politicians to do
something.
There is a line between true outrage and being a rodeo
clown. I don’t want rodeo clowns in the news business.
I don’t think Howard Kurtz does either. He ought to bring
the other Kurtz on his show.
Instead of learning how to be an obnoxious jerk like Beck,
we could learn how to be a Hall-of-Famer.
The news business would be better off all around.
Don McNay is Chairman
of McNay Settlement Group, where we hope Glenn Beck never comes to visit. You can write to him at
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
or read other things he has
written at www.donmcnay.com. His award-winning column is syndicated on the
CNHI News Service, and he is on the Board of Directors for the National Society
of Newspaper Columnists.
|